Accessing LAN devices using their local IP through OpenWRT Zerotier router

I've setup ZeroTier on my OpenWRT router and I'm able to remotely access all devices on my LAN expect for my windows machine. For some reason, the windows machine will only be accessible with it's ZT IP and not the Local IP. I was thinking it's a firewall issue on windows but I completely disabled firewall and it's still not working. I know my zerotier setup and routes are fine because it's working fine on my other devices. I can easily remotely access those other devices using their local LAN IP.

Any idea what might be the issue here? Would appreciate any tips.