I had thought about learning to shave with a safety razor for a couple years. When the pandemic hit, I thought it was a perfect time to learn.

I have been using shave butter, because on an academic level, it makes more sense to me to use a lubricant that adds oils instead of one that dries up your face. However, in 99.9% or the posts I read, people are raving about the greatness of shaving soap.

If I shave because I have to, not because I enjoy the act, is shave soap really that much better? Can anyone put into words why?

I enjoy the convenience of butter: not only is it faster and easier than soap, but since it doesn't lather you can see exactly what you're shaving.

So, am I being absurd? Am I missing something? Or is it just personal preference?